Puerto Rico should reject statehood. Here is why
Jan 6, 2023
Since 1898, Puerto Rico has been under the thumb of a giant Goliath – the U.S. – that doesn’t respect our constitution or protect the rights of its people. The obligation of a superpower to its territories is one of stewardship, protection and support for the benefit of both. The current relationship between the U.S. government and Puerto Rico is far from that. The locals have been treated more akin to subjects: pawns to be manipulated, lied to and mistreated.
That could soon change. In December, the U.S. House passed a bill that would allow Puerto Rico to hold a binding referendum to change the political status of Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico residents will be able to vote whether they want Puerto Rico to be independent, join the U.S. as its 51st state, or be a commonwealth with some links to the U.S. However, most locals have consistently rejected statehood, with good reason.
Under the stewardship of the U.S., the island’s resources were sold to the highest bidder. Abbott Laboratories, manufacturer of infant formula, was one of multiple companies that allowed chlorinated hydrocarbon chemicals linked to cancer and immunosuppression to spill out of underground tanks, according to reports. The island’s universal health care system has been replaced with a U.S. profit-based model, leaving thousands of the most vulnerable without health care and long lines at emergency rooms.
Our national monuments – such as El Morro, a Spanish Fortress built in 1539, that had always been free to visit – are now under control of the U.S. federal government that charges unaffordable fees. With unemployment reportedly at 40% for many years, the cost of visiting these monuments may be out of reach for most families. Places that were once admired and often visited by locals are now filled with thousands of tourists that overrun San Juan most of the year. The island has become a playground for the wealthy who purchase tax-free properties. However, these tax incentives are denied to locals.
The U.S. Military has built three bases on the most desirable coastal lands. On Vieques, a small island belonging to Puerto Rico, the locals were physically removed from their homes in the middle of the night in 1941.The Navy took over the two coastal areas pushing the locals to the center, thus cutting off their ability to make a living by fishing. The Navy was forced to leave in 2003, after many civilians died from the effects of toxic bomb fumes. Today the beaches are littered with rusty tanks and weapon-testing debris.
The U.S.’s influence has forever changed the health, education, financial, and transit systems in Puerto Rico. Big-box stores have changed the design of our coronal cities and towns. Corporations have built shopping malls, replacing the central plazas that were once the life of the community. Where families gathered for daily evening strolls. Other corporations, like Monsanto, are now developing GMOs on fertile soil that has been rendered poisonous. The privatization of the electric system has coincided with unprecedented blackouts and hardship. At the same time, the price of electricity has gone up seven times in one year.
Puerto Rico now has a chance to become a sovereign nation and get out from the colonial yoke of the U.S. government. By rejecting statehood and choosing commonwealth or independence, the people of Puerto Rico can return to being a free self-sustaining society.
Roberto K • Feb 5, 2023 at 8:21 pm
PR need be granted independence whereby America pays off all current PR government debt, and then provides a $100B sovereign wealth fund to Puerto Rico, but to be jointly managed by Puerto Rico and Norway.
This is the win win for all.
guillermo • Jan 17, 2023 at 8:11 am
I think the most sensible option for Puerto Rico is reunification with its motherland, Spain.
Dylan • Jan 10, 2023 at 4:17 pm
Remaining a Commonwealth, is to still be a part of the United States, so you wouldn’t be independent, but still a part of the United States.
Jose Alberto • Jan 9, 2023 at 9:13 am
Betsaida Rosario,
Please tell us, in detail, how Puerto Rico will find the money to run its own government if the people of Puerto Rico vote for independence. Like many things in life, there are advantages and disadvantages to being an independent nation. It is also true that Puerto Ricans have had many disagreements as to their island has been managed.
Luis Enrique Miranda Torres • Jan 17, 2023 at 11:07 am
We can run our own government when we are the owners and leader of our economic variables. With independence, we can do business with other countries. We can re-create our past universal healthcare system. We can protect our local business without the watch of the “Interstate Commerce Rule”. The Jones Act’s elimination can allow better prices on US imports to Puerto Rico. Without the so-called “Fiscal Board” we can handle the bankruptcy process in the future. One of the most important resources are in our professionals and universities. Independence must be followed by an economic transition from colonialism to self-government. The US has complete responsibility for this. Remember that nobody invite the United States to invade Puerto Rico in 1898. The bad shape of our economy is a result of the 1898 events.
Edwin Bartolomey • Jan 8, 2023 at 7:32 am
I am a US citizen who has parents who were born in Puerto Rico. I am all for Independence for PR., if PR can defend itself. What is the status of the military? Can PR defend itself from foreign invasion and occupation (e.g. Cuba)? Otherwise, state hood may be the better option or continuing as a Commonwealth of the US. PR citizens will make the best decision for their future. Ask Hawaiian residents how they feel now, so many years later after statehood. Was it worth it to them? I do not know. However, I will completely support the PR citizens choice, whichever way she chooses to govern herself.
Jose • Jan 7, 2023 at 8:15 pm
Thank you for the headline, but you’re too late realizing the obvious. Puerto Rico has already repudiated statehood on seven ocassions: 1952, 1967, 1993, 1998, 2012, 2017 and 2020. And in each an every one of those occasions, they also repudiated Independence, for being far worse that a forced statehood. Puerto Rican have always, in all those self determination referendums, demanded to keep the commonwealth option. See if you can freaking learn to respect that.